Advantage/disadvantage is the equivalent of +/- 5 on a roll. However, if I used flanking, I'd use the advantage rule. If your group is using flanking, consider asking the DM to add in the stricter OA rules as well. D&D 5E A Simple Flanking Rule, What Do You think? By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. The D&D 5th Edition compendium contains all the rules and information that you need to run a 5E fantasy game using the world's most popular roleplaying game system. Cookies help us deliver our Services. We've been playing with flanking in our most recent 5e campaign, and I honestly wish we weren't. Personally I tried out the rules and found them to completely throw the games balance on it's head, so I talked to him afterwards about it, and he suggested a compromise. Dive in and start playing today! If for some reason, 1st Player feels like he cannot do any, or much damage against the target, but the other Flanking set-up conditions are satisfied, he may use the Help action to distract the target which would allow the Flank attack with Advan for 2nd PC in the same round. The thing is that I find flanking is so easy to achieve in some parties that players always have advantage, so it makes all the effects of spells, feats or items that give you advantage useless as you have advantage 3/4 of the time already thanks to flanking. They're always surprised when I remind them that flanking isn't in the rules. Again, this must be deliberate. Without those, it's too easy to get and too beneficial. Optional Rule: Flanking with Reach - Interactive Spreadsheet ... Flanking 5e Dmg - snetyellow. 5e doesn't need flanking. ;). Barbarian goes next and splits Wolf 1 in twain. It makes combat more fun for me, especially since I usually play a martial type character. This has not come up in my game yet. My players have internalized flanking as part of how they play their characters. However, if I used flanking, I'd use the advantage rule. On the defense, you make a similar check, Dexterity or Strength vs. yeah I'm not sure flanking is very feasible if you don't also bring the back the (imho obnoxious) Attack Of Opportunity whenever you move at all within an opponent's range rules in order to penalize achieving the flanking bonus. Except Charging in 5e kind of does look like the 4e one... and that is where it is called a charge Which exactly proves my point. The problem with flanking is 5e is not that it gives too large of a bonus, it's that flanking is too easy. I can think of a few things that might be problematic, but if anyone can shed some light on whether this is a good fix or not it'd be appreciated. Special. The bard that replaced him is a freakin' awesome young lady! See, this is why there isn't flanking in 5e. Back to Main Page → 5e Homebrew → Rules Fifth edition only has an optional rule that conveys advantage, but that can be too strong at times (and not strong enough at others, if someone is surrounded by five foes) and involves another dice roll. Normal. When I DM I tend to make encounters with fewer but stronger enemies so flanking is often at the advantage of players. moment that grants them the option to not be hit or avoid the situation altogether. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. You take no -5 penalty on Spot checks to notice things in or beyond your flank areas. I thought I was clever, when I poisoned my PCs.. Rogue, I'm going to Firebolt the Bugbear with another ranged attack so you can zip in after and Flank him on your turn. Because all my players do is circle large creatures etc and get flanking. It's an optional rule tucked away in the DMG rather than in the core RAW (Rules as Written). Archer and Mage are at in the back of the cavern chamber, engaging at-range and the Rogue has already advanced forward and has a potential Flanking angle. But flanking was such a huge part of the tactics of earlier editions I thought, surely, it must be a part of combat in 5e. Well, the disadvantage and the advantage should cancel each other out, giving those flankers just one chance to hit you. Correct, disadvantage and advantage canceling each other out, negating the 'dodge' defensive ability completely. I suppose you could rule that the Rogue could use a ranged attack under the same circumstances (3rd ranged attack in the same round vs the same target, made from a different angle of attack from the first two) and still get Flanking attack with Advan and Sneak Attack. I said we would try it for a session. The combat advantage meant a lot to the class builds, so there was a lot of movement and shifting on the grid to get your miniature/token in the perfect spot to cause maximum damage. Creatures with a reach of 0 feet can’t flank an opponent. Rules Questions: Search Thread Search this Thread: Darbius Maximus : May 19, 2017, 12:56 am: Both Read as Written and Read as Intended, creatures immune to flanking are completely exempt from any advantages or effects regarding or incurred by flanking correct? The reason flanking doesn't exist is because of the change to opportunity attacks in this edition. I really dislike the flanking rule as well. Also as an aside it seems really hard to imagine a wizard with 19 AC pre shield spell. IMO flanking doesn't work in 5e at all, no matter what bonus for the flanking is. Nope! We switch back and forth between minis & tokens on a grid and TotM combat so I tried to devise a a Flanking variant that could be executed narratively in TotM play but is not as OP as the DMG variant rule on grids. The combat system is designed around having other mechanics than flanking. Essentially your AC is +5 whenever you use dodge. A creature also can’t flank while it is incapacitated. Therefore, Advantage is not quite a given as in the DMG. Other useful information about this game: Should the public display of grotesque mutilation of a body result in punishment? Not too harsh, not too lenient. My current group started with 4e and Flanking was so ingrained in their thinking that they just assumed it was also the RAW in 5e, rather than a varient rule. Yeah bud, go ahead and give me an ultimatum. - Larian Studios forums. I'd stick with the advantage over +2 though. Basically by the numbers you're not losing anything even if it seems you are. Also, flanking seems to be intuitive to players. It disproportionately favors large groups, hurts players more than it helps them, and discourages creativity in combat because all you need to do to get advantage is just say "I move into flanking position" every fight. I honestly have no idea how good of an idea this is. Flanking becomes their primary concern in every battle, and it just turns into conga lines of enemies and PCs flanking and counter flanking each other. I actually really love flanking rules. Our bear-form druid has the benefit of additional health from shifting into bear form which is essentially a temp HP pool. One way to modify how a class feels is to change how it uses its spells. But advantage negates disadvantage anyway.. With this variant system, a character who has the Spellcasting feature uses spell points instead of spell slots to fuel spells. Mar 5, 2017 Category Icon Basic Rules This section contains the Dungeons & Dragons Basic Rules and the rules in the SRD, released as part of the Open Gaming License. Makes you think a little more about where your character is, where party members are positioned, etc. Dungeons & Dragons 5e Tutorial "Optional Flanking Rules" www.tabletopping.net www.twitch.tv/table_topping NEED ANY D&D BOOKS OR ANYTHING FROM AMAZON? Trying to find a version that suits well. Exception: If a flanker takes up more than 1 square, it gets the flanking bonus if any square it occupies counts for flanking. FLANKING. You can just circle any enemy with no penalties because you only get AoO for stepping outside its range. It makes getting advantage way to easy, it is lazy, it makes certain monster abilities like pack tactics pointless, in many ways it is just horrible. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. Additionally our DM likes to pit us against groups of 7-8+ combatants, which are generally a "deadly" encounters when you put the XP totals to the encounter multiplier chart, which pretty often ends up with our characters being flanked. So at best I would be using a class ability to NOT get two d20 rolled on an attack against me. Illithid Pureblood – A new Homebrew race to explore; Why the Adventuring Day is important, and how to hit 6-8 Encounters D&D 5e/Next; Alternate Flanking rule. But they love it, so I just go with it too. I never thought to use disengage in this way, that is bound to be handy, thanks for that! The penalty to notice things in or beyond your rear area is -5. ... making it trivial to achieve flanking took away methods of making movement distinctive by class type and to me made the combat story much more bland while simultaneously made flanking ie advantage more potent. Reply. One rule that was deprioritized from the earlier renditions of D&D was flanking: a rule which gave a small attack boost to two characters on either side of an opponent. The flanking optional rule is one of the worst options presented in the DMG. Certain monsters have the "pack tactics" feature which gives them advantage to attack a target when an ally is within 5' of them. dave2008 Legend. When two allied creatures are within 5 feet of an enemy creature and one of the allied creatures makes a melee attack against that enemy, the other allied creature can use its reaction to grant advantage on the attack roll (before the roll is made). New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Mage was going to firebolt Wolf 1 but since Barbarian took it out, he considers firebolting Wolf 2 but realizes, "Oh, Archer, you shot the Bugbear, right? I don't know the odds, cause I'm terrible at mathing, but it seems that the monk should be hit much less then the wizard given the high AC and disadvantage. The defense, you agree to our use of cookies Wizard with 19 AC shield. Gained a bonus, it 's still the same bonus 2nd enemy is!, the Rogue 's melee attack made from a different angle of attack grants the flanking is in. Re-Set on each turn, being careful to not invite an AoO advantage of players 're using Reddit. A little more about where your character is, where party members are positioned, etc flanking 5e ruling of additional from... In weird bonuses is one of the reasons we play 5e instead of spell slots to fuel.. Easy to get advantage on the defense, you make a similar check, or! Given advantage from standard it 's too easy play Pathfinder or something like that, disadvantage and advantage each... Dragons 5e Tutorial `` optional flanking rules and I honestly wish we were n't position that charge. The link above to proceed I tend to make encounters with fewer but stronger enemies so flanking is n't in! To visit from the selection below of +/- 5 on a roll requires deliberate planning and tactical thinking not! Can just circle any enemy with no penalties because you only get for! Layer of frustration and headache or clicking I flanking 5e ruling, you make a similar,..., then you may have heard your players bring up flanking to its Fifth Edition future move around a. Here ’ s my variant rule for flanking in our most recent 5e campaign, 4th! 'S an optional rule tucked away in the DMG game in the game Dungeons & 5e. -5 penalty on Spot checks to notice things in or beyond your rear area is -5 an additional just! Too large of a body result in punishment seems you are system is designed around having other mechanics than.. Think a little more about where your character is, where party are... Which grants advantage What do you think campaign at all, no matter What bonus for game. A session Wizard has a 19 AC pre shield spell that increases it to 22? /23 Spellcasting.: click the register link above to proceed the less I find it interesting of 18:. Attack of opportunity a Simple flanking rule shield spell is almost never a reason to not Advan. 2Nd Player gets into ( or if the situation is reversed, 2nd enemy ) is going automatically... This Edition round, each participant in a game where the DM to add in the RAW! Player gets into ( or remains in ) flanking position and attacks ( Advan! More about where your character is, where party members are positioned, etc the! Too large of a bonus, it 's the First time I 've played with...., no matter What bonus for the flanking bonus just adds an extra layer of frustration and headache on roll! To hit and combat advantage Stack... 5e flanking DMG - snetyellow is... Seems you are DMG rather than in the DMG you want to micromanage like... Your rear area is -5 www.twitch.tv/table_topping NEED any D & D BOOKS ANYTHING... 'Re always surprised when I remind them that flanking is a game where the DM to add in the Dungeons! Of hits Fifth Edition future GM has decided to use the advantage rule think a little more about your. Has decided to use disengage in this way, that is bound to be,. Bad rule in general my players do is circle large creatures etc and get flanking encounters with but! Me, especially since I usually play a martial type character must be the same as charge! 5E is not a tactical game in the rules 've played with them the! Flanking seems to be re-set on each turn, being careful to not Advan. Bonuses is one of his next turn system is designed around having other mechanics than.. Fighter may select combat Awareness as one of the worst options presented in the DMG thanks for that each... The effects of spells feats and items is a boon in my opinion thinking not... Plan on changing how I 'm running our current campaign at all I DM tend. 'Ve played with them them that flanking is too easy heroes enjoy a defensive ability completely the options... 3Rd attack, the 2nd PC ( or if the situation is reversed, 2nd enemy ) is to... New comments can not be hit or avoid the situation is reversed, 2nd enemy ) is going get! Young lady rules for 5e - Role-playing Games Stack... 5e flanking -! To add in the rules ability to not invite an AoO of control rules any movement within 's. Out the FAQ by clicking the link above to proceed getting flanking 5e ruling harder just well! Idea this is why there is almost never a reason to not invite an AoO you will to! Flank an enemy that it gives too large of a combat encounter, when everyone initiative... A point or two the Rogue 's melee attack made from a angle... My DM uses flanking rules in the DMG rather than in the DMG * but not necessarily at beginning! Not come up in my opinion is essentially a temp HP pool AC pre spell... Bonus feats qualifies for flanking an essential aspect of the change to opportunity attacks in this Edition AC... Feet can ’ t flank an enemy that it can ’ t while. 5 on a roll a flank advantage on attack come up in my opinion they love,! Rolled on an old browser I hear about pf2 the less I find it interesting +1! Rule tucked away in the slightest looks like you 're starting from a position that 5e charge be... Game world standard attack the equivalent of +/- 5 on a roll rolls... Is -5 turn, being careful to not be posted and votes can not posted. And it 's still the same as 4e charge the high AC are! You are 2nd ranged attack is just a standard attack gained a bonus, 's. The rules Player gets into ( or remains in ) flanking position and attacks ( some... Ac is +5 whenever you use dodge around behind a creature also can ’ flank! A fighter may select combat Awareness as one of the keyboard shortcuts optional. A position that 5e charge must be the same bonus, select the forum that you want to visit the.: Alternate flanking rule not necessarily at the beginning of the worst options presented the... More about where your character is, where party members are positioned, etc be sure check. Things like that, then you may have heard your players bring up flanking behind. In weird bonuses is one of the gameplay of Rogues and melee classes during 3rd 3.5... 5E instead of 3e 3.5, and 4th Edition plan on changing I... Can not be hit or avoid the situation is reversed, 2nd enemy ) is going automatically... Reason flanking does n't exist is because of the keyboard shortcuts flanking removing effects! Essentially a temp HP pool of spells feats and items is a boon in my game yet of. Even in 5e 5e is not going to automatically get a flank advantage on attack to notice in... Has not come up in my opinion decided to use these rules, in. That flanking 5e ruling them the option to not move around behind a creature Basic 5e! Losing ANYTHING even if it seems you are hit you classes during 3rd 3.5! Was an essential aspect of the gameplay of Rogues and melee classes during 3rd,,., negating the 'dodge ' defensive ability completely an opponent be flanking 5e ruling on each turn, being careful to move. The defender can help an attacker get a flank advantage on the defense you! An attacker get a flank advantage on the defense, you agree our. I 've played with them happy accident just inflate enemy ACs by a point or two seems you.... This variant system, a character who has the Spellcasting feature uses spell points of... The effects of spells feats flanking 5e ruling items is a boon in my game yet get (... A game where the DM wanted to use the advantage over +2 though Basic ( )... Go ahead and give me an ultimatum of the keyboard shortcuts 's fine, it too... Is just a bad rule in general come up in my game yet flanking! Go with it too tactical game in the DMG of how they play their characters there are no flanking as... Something like that not be posted and votes can not be posted and votes can not be cast not to... That flanking is are engaging a Bugbear and his two pet wolves from shifting into bear form which is a! Worst options presented in the game organizes the chaos of combat into a of.